Free USA Shipping $55+ | Spend $75+ for FREE Gifts β€” View Rewards β†’

✨ Create a Magical Nativity Scene Sign with Sharon Hankins 🌟

✨ Create a Magical Nativity Scene Sign with Sharon Hankins 🌟

DIY Nativity Scene Sign with Sharon Hankins of I Restore Stuff

Join Sharon Hankins of I Restore Stuff as she creates a peaceful and timeless Nativity Scene Sign using Essential Stencil’s Christmas restock collection. This beautiful piece captures the meaning of the season β€” perfect for your holiday home dΓ©cor or as a heartfelt handmade gift.


Table of Contents


Materials Used


Step-by-Step Instructions

1. Create a Night Sky Background

Start by staining a 12x16" board using a damp cloth and Midnight Blue paint to achieve a rich night sky effect. Leave about one-third of the bottom unpainted for the ground.

Staining board with Midnight Blue for night sky

2. Stain the Ground Area

Use Elmwood paint as a natural stain for the lower third of your board, creating the ground beneath the nativity. Let both colors dry completely before moving on.

Staining board with Elmwood paint

3. Add the Nativity Scene

Center the Nativity Scene Stencil on the board. Using a stencil brush and white paint, carefully fill in the design. Apply a second coat if you prefer a more opaque finish.

Stenciling the Nativity Scene

4. Stencil β€œThe First Noel”

Take β€œThe First Noel” design from the 1-inch Christmas Words Stencil Pack and position it along the bottom. Stencil the words with the same white paint to tie the whole piece together.

Stenciling The First Noel

5. Add Stars to the Sky

Using the same Nativity stencil, randomly place and stencil a few stars in the top area of your board. This adds depth and sparkle to your night sky scene.

Adding stars to Nativity Sign

6. Highlight with Metallic Gold

Reposition the stencil over the largest star, then lightly apply a second coat using metallic gold paint. This gives your piece a subtle shimmer and makes that guiding star stand out beautifully.

Adding metallic gold to the star


Helpful Tips

  • Always offload excess paint from your brush before stenciling to prevent bleeding.
  • Use painter’s tape to secure your stencil and ensure crisp, clean edges.
  • Try mixing metallic paint with clear glaze for a soft, shimmering finish.
  • Let your piece dry completely before sealing or displaying.

Final Reveal

Finished Nativity Scene Sign Project

This Nativity Scene Sign perfectly captures the quiet beauty of Christmas night. The rich stained background and gold-touched star make it an elegant statement piece for your holiday dΓ©cor.


We loved crafting this project with Sharon Hankins of I Restore Stuff β€” an Essential Stencil Ambassador who inspires creativity every week! Don’t forget to shop the featured stencils and brushes below to recreate this look at home.

πŸ›οΈ Shop the Nativity Scene Stencil
πŸ›οΈ Shop the 1-Inch Christmas Words Stencil Set
πŸ›οΈ Shop the Stencil Brush Set

✨ Want more holiday inspiration? Explore our full Christmas Stencil Collection.


Watch the Full Tutorial

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.